Your ICP Might Be Holding You Back

Most sales and marketing teams cling to their ICP like it’s gospel.

We get it. It gives you structure. It keeps you from boiling the ocean. It makes your TAM feel a little less intimidating. And it looks really nice in a pitch deck.

But here’s what we see at Howdy Sales: for a lot of teams, the ICP isn’t a compass - it’s a crutch.

It becomes a substitute for curiosity. It keeps teams chasing “fit” instead of urgency. And it gives a false sense of control in a market that’s anything but static.

The ICP Trap

ICP thinking starts with good intentions: “Let’s figure out who our best customers are so we can go find more of them.” But somewhere along the way, it turns into:

• “We only sell to 50–200 employee SaaS companies.”

• “Our buyer has to be a VP or above.”

• “If they’re not using XYZ tool, they’re not a fit.”

The problem isn’t that these things are wrong. It’s that they’re incomplete.

A perfect-fit prospect with no urgency is a waste of your best pitch. And a messy-fit account with momentum might be your next big win.

People don’t buy because they’re in your ICP. They buy because something’s changing.

That’s the part too many teams ignore.

Context Is the New ICP

If you’ve ever won a deal that surprised you (or lost one that shouldn’t have slipped away) you’ve felt this tension.

• A “bad fit” company signs a contract in a week.

• A “perfect fit” ghost you after the demo.

What made the difference? Context.

• A leadership shakeup

• A vendor renewal gone sour

• A new GTM motion that needs support

• A painful board meeting that pushed a decision

These aren’t firmographics. They’re buying signals. They’re dynamic, not static. And they’re way more powerful than any persona slide.

At Howdy Sales, we call this Signal Stacking: looking for the moments of friction that suggest a buyer is closer to action, regardless of whether they “fit the mold.”

How to Build a Living Context Profile

Here’s a simple framework to help your team focus less on who fits and more on who’s moving. We call it the Living Context Profile, and it evolves every week.

Step 1: Shift Your Mindset from Static to Dynamic

Instead of asking, “Does this account match our ICP?”

Start asking:

• “What’s changing for this buyer right now?”

• “What friction are they feeling that we can solve?”

• “What signals suggest this is worth a conversation?”

Step 2: Create Your Living Context Profile Doc

We recommend starting this in a shared doc or Notion page that’s easy to update. Each week, your team should contribute new insights.

Your doc should include:

Step 3: Audit Past Deals with a “Trigger Lens”

Pull your last 10 closed-won and 10 closed-lost deals. For each, ask:

• What was happening in the buyer’s world at the time?

• Did a job change trigger the conversation?

• Were they already evaluating alternatives?

• Were we too early? Too late?

  
  

You’ll start spotting patterns. Not just who buys, but when and why.

Step 4: Build a Trigger Signal Library (the Smart Way)

Most sales teams stop at surface-level signals:

• “They raised a Series B.”

• “They’re hiring a new VP.”

• “They use Salesforce.”

These are table stakes. Everyone sees them. Everyone is hitting the same accounts.

What wins deals is the second layer: Signals that are real, recent, and often hidden.

We break them into two categories:

Standard Signals (Everyone Has Access)

These are easy to find with off-the-shelf tools like Crunchbase, LinkedIn, or job boards. Still useful, especially when stacked.

Company-Specific Signals (Requires AI or Deep Research)

These are harder to find - and that’s exactly why they work.

These signals don’t live on a LinkedIn profile. You have to dig - or automate the dig.

Step 5: Review & Evolve Weekly

The point of a Living Context Profile is that it’s alive. It should grow and evolve every week.

Block 30 minutes each Friday to:

• Review wins/losses

• Refine context signals

• Update the doc with fresh language or triggers

  
  

Eventually, this becomes your real ICP in motion.

Tidy Doesn’t Win

The tidy version of your buyer is tempting. It’s easier to operationalize. But tidy doesn’t buy. Tidy doesn’t respond. Tidy doesn’t move budget.

Real buyers are messy, but they show signals. If you’re paying attention, you’ll catch them before your competitors do.

So ditch the slide deck persona for a living, breathing, messy doc. And start selling to real people, not made-up ones.

🌵